There is one team in college football this year: the Georgia Bulldogs. And although other individuals may be having exceptional seasons, this year is a failure if Georgia does not win the national championship. PERIOD. FULL STOP!
Welcome (Back) to the Ole College Try, which is my take on college football via a weekly column on college football after each weekend's games. The column is meant to be a recap of the season to date, with an emphasis on last week's games. I write this column as if every player is a Heisman Trophy candidate. Why? Because it is ridiculously ludicrous (is there any other kind of ludicrous, besides Ludacris?) that the networks, including the World-Wide Leader, nay, especially the World-Wide Leader, emphasize the Heisman Trophy race all season at the expense of everything else. Consider this my sarcastic homage to stupid reporting.
Heisman Watch
Quarterback Edition
Favorite - Darian Mensah - Miami - Still at the top of the list, and a virtual lock to be on the Heisman dais in December. Mensah led Miami to a 36-25 victory over a tough Duke squad that was fighting for the right to play Miami in the ACC Championship game. Mensah finished 30/41 for 382 yards and 1 TD (and 0 INTs) as Miami pulled away from Duke (Duke's last score came at the virtual end of the game to make the spread 11.) Mensah is clearly the best quarterback in the NCAA this year, as this is his second-straight great game without Malachi Toney.
Rising - Gunnar Stockton - Georgia - He is not overwhelming anybody with statistics - mostly because he doesn't have to with this loaded squad - but the Bulldog quarterback has been playing some amazing football. He finished 18-24 for 252 yards and 1 TD before being pulled in the blowout 48-21 victory over Missouri.
Sleeper - Noah Fifita - Arizona - In all honesty, he should be in the "rising" category, but I just couldn't place him there to make mention for Stockton. Fifita was 27/43 for 356 yards and 3 TDs against only 1 interception as Arizona came Oh-So-Close to dethroning the undefeated Utah Utes - losing 40-39. Fifita has all the makings of a late-round draft pick that in 2028 or 2029 will get a surprise start due to some NFL starter's injury, and never give that starting role up.
Falling - Sam Leavitt - LSU - The much-ballyhooed transfer hand-selected by new coach Lane Kiffin has been marred by turnover problems; and he threw 3 more interceptions against Texas as the Longhorns win the game 22-21 on a last-second TD throw by Arch Manning. Leavitt - and LSU - fall to 6-4; 3-4 in the SEC, in what has to be the most disappointing season by any school in modern history.
Running Back Edition
Favorite - Nate Sheppard - Duke - I have been waiting for the right week to bring out Sheppard's name - and this week did not disappoint. Playing against the number 1 rush defense in the FBS, Sheppard gained 131 yards on 16 carries and scoring 2 TDs on the ground, while adding an additional 93 yards on 12 catches, showcasing legitimate NFL dual-threat ability. He also was 2/2 throwing the ball for 16 yards, including one big first down when the Blue Devils were still in the game before Miami pulled away. He should also be in New York City as a Heisman finalist (with Mensah and Smith).
Rising - Nate Frazier - Georgia - Like Stockton, his statistics are muzzled because the team is just too good, but the talent cannot be denied. Frazier gained 74 yards on 14 carries and hit paydirt 3 times as Georgia annihilated Missouri 48-21.
Falling - Jaden Baugh - Florida - The talent and the tough-running ability is there, but the blocking has not been consistent, and the fact that defenses are keying on the Gator running back is making running lanes difficult to find for Baugh. It is, however, opening up other players to be successful in this offense, like quarterback Aaron Philo's 102 yards and 1 TD in Florida's upset win at Kentucky.
Sleeper - Daniel Bray - Utah - The second-fiddle in Utah's running game to quarterback Devon Dampier, Bray rushed for 197 yards and 1 TD in as Utah survived Arizona on the road 40-39. Although limited in carries, Bray has maintained an almost 9 yards per carry average, and is one of the reasons the offense is so dangerous for the undefeated Utes.
Wide Receiver Edition
Favorite - Jeremiah Smith - Ohio State - Will win the Heisman trophy; barring something absolutely bizarre in the next month. Smith caught 11 balls for 117 yards and 1 TD - including an absolutely amazing sideline ballet-catch that would have been ruled incomplete if it was made by Elija Loftin - as Ohio State defeated Northwestern 28-19.
Rising - Jesse Legree - Oregon State - The first-year statistical eye-opener caught 12 balls for 140 yards and 1 touchdown as Oregon State fell to Boise State 46-41 in Boise. Legree is tied for 6th in receptions, 1st in yards, and tied for 1st in TD receptions in FBS.
Sleeper - Carlos Hernandez - Wake Forest - People need to "Wake" up to the fact that the Demon Deacons are REALLY GOOD!!! They should absolutely be ranked in the playoff top 12 NOW. They annihilated potential ACC-title contender SMU on the road 49-7, blitzing out to a 42-0 halftime lead. Hernandez gained 94 yards on 6 catches and 1 touchdown, and is in the running for an All-America spot.
Falling - Malachi Toney - Miami - Still out 4 to 6 weeks. His physical therapy is reportedly going very well, so we should see him for the playoffs and maybe, MAYBE?, for the ACC Championship game. This is great news for Miami so long as they don't stumble against Virginia Tech and/or Boston College, but the missed time hurts Toney's standing as far as the Heisman and All-American awards.
Defensive Edition
No change in personnel this week, only in the rankings.
5. Ellis Robinson IV - CB - Georgia - The playmaker is fast-rising up draft boards with his shut-down man-to-man coverage skills. A big reason Georgia is so dominating defensively.
4. LaDainian Fields - CB - Oklahoma State - Leads the FBS with 7 interceptions.
3. Colin Simmons - EDGE - Texas - Tied for the FBS lead with 10 1/2 sacks, even with missing two games. Had 11 tackles against LSU this week, although no sacks. But still - 11 tackles from the EDGE!!!
2. Nicholas Rodriguez - LB - Missouri - Third in the FBS (and first in the SEC) in tackles with 105, and 3 1/2 sacks from the middle. Definitely reminding people of Jacob Rodriguez - his brother - who is a leading candidate for NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year with the Miami Dolphins.
1. Chris Cole - LB - Georgia - Best defender in the NCAA. Can run, tackle, rush, cover - you name it. Had 6 total tackles against Missouri this week.
Player(s) to Watch
Devon Dampier - QB, Utah. The dual-threat QB has done nothing other than lead Utah to an undefeated season to-date and with very winnable games against TCU and West Virginia remaining, a likely undefeated regular season and birth in the Big 12 Championship game!
My New Favorite Player
Thomas Castellanos - QB, Texas Tech. In his four games starting for the 9-1 Red Raiders since his reinstatement, all Castellanos has done has been to lead Texas Tech to point totals of 53, 34, 53, and 52 in going 4-0 and headed towards a potential date in the Big 12 Championship game against Devon Dampier and Utah - if they can take care of business against Baylor and TCU.
Players of the Week
6. Aaron Philo, QB - Florida. The much maligned QB recovered his starting spot from Trammel Jones, and all he did was to go into Lexington against the 11th-ranked Wildcats and protect the football with no interceptions (16/24 for 119) and also lead the Gators with 102 yards rushing and a touchdown.
5. Jonaz Walton, RB - Notre Dame. Gained 141 yards and 1 TD on 15 carries in Notre Dame's 41-7 route of Boston College.
4. Nate Bailey, WR - Harvard. Bailey caught 13 passes for 113 yards and 2 TDs, as the Crimson clinched the Ivy League title, and the conference's automatic berth in the FCS playoffs!
3. Maalik Murphy, QB - Oregon State. The former Texas and Duke quarterback is settling in nicely in Oregon State, and this week he was 31/39 for 396 and 3 TDs - with 1 interception - as the Beavers gave Boise State a scare 46-41.
2. Noah Fifita, QB - Arizona. 27/43 for 356 yards and 3 TDs as Arizona gave Utah's its biggest scare of the season, falling 40-39.
1. Nate Sheppard, RB - Duke. He gained 224 total yards and scored 3 TDs as Duke fell to Miami 36-25.
Goat of the Week (Player Edition)
Sam Leavitt, QB - LSU. Three interceptions in the game for their CFP lives. The Tigers were still in the game to the end, literally the end, when Arch Manning throws a game-ending TD pass for the Longhorns to defeat the Tigers 22-21.
Goat of the Week (Coach Edition)
Lane Kiffin, LSU. And it could not have happened to a better coach. Remember how dreadfully he left Mississippi last year, and then stated they would have won the playoffs had he stayed. Then he toyed with Florida before selecting LSU. Then he played games in the portal before demanding Sam Leavitt. And then he played games with the eligibility rule by threatening to use players that were in NFL preseason camps and signed to contracts. And then he proceeding to lose 4 games to date!
Predicted Playoffs Semi-Final Match Ups (By Seeding Only)
(1) Georgia v. (4) Miami (2) Utah v. Notre Dame (3)
Final Unbeatens
FBS - UCLA, Utah
(1) Georgia v. (4) Miami (2) Utah v. Notre Dame (3)
Final Unbeatens
FBS - UCLA, Utah
FCS - Tarleton State
Rant(s) of the Week
Same rant as last week, which I will keep here for reading. Why, because Jeremiah Smith catches a ball on the sideline with zero - AND I MEAN ZERO feet in bounds after he secures the ball. His entire body falls out-of-bounds. Completed catch!!!
"OK - yes, I am a fan. But that Elijah Loftin catch - WAS A CATCH. He secured the ball (with two hands mind you) and had one foot (actually two feet) in the endzone. To quote Lt. Daniel Kaffey, "These are the facts; and they are indisputable!" Loftin then has to complete the catch by either making a football move, or with enough elapsed time that a football move could have been made. What did Loftin do at that point? He got his second foot in, he brought the ball from the air to his chest, and then he stepped out-of-bounds. All three of those are football moves. One of those by itself completes the catch. Touchdown. Keep in mind this is not a play where Loftin went to the ground, so he does not have to complete the catch through the ground - just through the "football move." And that he did, indisputably, as the contact from the DB occurs after he is out-of-bounds. That, my friends, is a touchdown!"
Under Performance of the Week
SMU Mustangs. SMU with a win over Wake Forest would tie the Demon Deacons and Louisville for second place in the ACC and solidify a chance at making the conference Championship game against Miami, and all they do is get housed 42-0 by halftime.
Last Week's Trivia Answer
Utah and UCLA are the last remaining undefeated teams in FBS. Each has had one number 1 overall NFL draft pick. Who are they, and what year were they were drafted.
Answer: For UCLA, Troy Aikman in 1989. For Utah, Alex Smith in 2005
Trivia Question of the Week
Inspired by the incredible performance by Nate Sheppard and his 224 total yards against Miami this weekend, a double header:
Who holds the ACC single-game record for rushing yards, and how many? Who holds the ACC single-game record for total yards, and how many?
Match-up(s) to Watch
5. Virginia Tech v. Miami - Given the Hokies record and play, this is not actually a big game. But the dearth of good games this weekend, and the fact that GameDay will be in Coral Gables, allows me to place this game in this slot.
5. Virginia Tech v. Miami - Given the Hokies record and play, this is not actually a big game. But the dearth of good games this weekend, and the fact that GameDay will be in Coral Gables, allows me to place this game in this slot.
4. Kentucky v. Missouri - Losses by both squads this weekend - Kentucky to Florida and Missouri at the hands of Georgia - keeps this game from being number 2, or even number 1. Kentucky needs this win to stay in the playoff hunt.
3. Georgia v. South Carolina - This should be higher, but Georgia's recent dominance means this game is likely to get out of control quickly.
2. LSU v. Tennessee - Tennessee would love to deliver this knockout blow to Lane Kiffin, its former coach!
1. Yale v. Harvard (at Fenway Park in Boston) - THE GAME!!!
