The SEC has flipped upside-down, and not in the standings or in the games, but in the public relations. The entire story of the offseason was Lane Kiffin's move to LSU, and the potential use of players from NFL training camps by ... Lane Kiffin. And the most impactful new coach in the SEC is ... NOT LANE KIFFIN!!! It is clearly WILL STEIN!!! Kentucky defeated LSU 35-34 in overtime, by converting a game-winning two-point conversion in the first OT to snatch the victory - for the second straight weekend!!! Will Stein is clearly the difference between a losing and winning program.
Welcome to the Ole College Try, which is my take on college football via a weekly column on college football after each weekend's games. The column is meant to be a recap of the season to date, with an emphasis on last week's games. I write this column as if every player is a Heisman Trophy candidate. Why? Because it is ridiculously ludicrous (is there any other kind of ludicrous, besides Ludacris?) that the networks, including the World-Wide Leader, nay, especially the World-Wide Leader, emphasize the Heisman Trophy race all season at the expense of everything else. Consider this my sarcastic homage to stupid reporting.
Ideally this post would occur weekly, but no guarantees as I try to slip in some writing during mental breaks from my actual job. So far, I have been able to post weekly - let's see how long I can keep this up.
Heisman Watch
Quarterback Edition
Favorite - Darian Mensah - Miami - A bye week for Miami, but Mensah is still the favorite - at least from the quarterback position. We all know the favorite is Jeremiah Smith (OVERWHELMINGLY!)
Rising - Drew Mestemaker - Oklahoma State - Remember, this team unexpectedly beat Oregon early in the season. Mesemaker, who threw for 304 yards and 2 TDs (on 19/28 passing), led the Cowboys to a 42-28 victory over UCF this week and has been making some noise as a first-round draft pick in 2027.
Sleeper - LaNorris Sellars - South Carolina - My apologies to Mr. Sellars for naming him as the "Falling QB" in last week's column. Although, if you go back and read it, I specifically stated that he had "all of the talent in the world ... but this team is soooooooo bad," so I wasn't really critiquing him. South Carolina went into Gainesville and just absolutely HOUSED the Gators 38-19 behind Sellars, who was 23/35 for 279 yards and 4 TDs, while adding 20 yards and 1 TD on the ground.
Falling - Sam Leavitt - LSU - An uber-talented QB, who was the primary target of a lot of teams in the portal this year, with Miami having to "settle" for Darian Mensah. He hasn't played poorly, but he is a victim of LSU's two losses and the over-hype on/by/for Lane Kiffin. He was a respectable 25/34 for 275 yards with 2 TDs and 1 INT in the 35-34 defeat at the hands of Kentucky.
Running Back Edition
Favorite - Jamal Roberts - Missouri - Last week's riser, is now this week's favorite - at least as much of a favorite as any running back can be this week. He gained 222 yards on 34 carries and rushed for 2 TDs while adding 3 catches in Missouri's 27-6 annihilation of Texas A&M. He has 828 yards rushing on the season, good enough for second in the FBS.
Rising - Dylan Riley - Boise State - Riley is the workhorse behind the Broncos push for the FBS playoffs (see what I did there). He gained 150 yards in 19 carries and scoring once on the ground, while adding a team-high 64 yards on 4 catches and another score in a 38-31 win over Fresno State. He currently leads the nation in rushing yards with 835 (albeit only 7 ahead of Roberts).
Falling - Jaden Baugh, Florida - He did score a TD, but gained only 59 yards against South Carolina in a game that saw the UF offense be totally powerless against the Gamecocks.
Sleeper - CJ Baxter - Kentucky - Somebody on the Wildcats needs to get some love in this column, as they are 5-1 and winning games "they are not supposed to win." Baxter gained 123 yards on 19 carries and scored 2 TDs in Kentucky's upset over LSU. He is averaging 5.6 yards per carry and has scored 8 TDs on the season.
Wide Receiver Edition
Favorite - Jeremiah Smith - Ohio State - It is - and barring injury always will be - Jeremiah Smith. Only 4 catches this week, but turned that into 93 yards and 2 TDs, as he sat most of the second half in an easy 45-16 win over Maryland to set up a HUGE matchup this week against Indiana.
Falling - Malachi Toney - Miami - Just because of a bye week, but seems like he will always be 1A, or maybe 2, compared to Smith, especially since Miami spreads the ball more often.
Rising - Isaiah Sategna, III - Oklahoma - Rutgers - Only because K.J. Duff of Rutgers had a bye week. Sategna only had 5 catches for 64 yards, but two of those catches were HUGE plays on the last game-winning drive setting up Tate Sandell's game-winning 47-yard field goal as time expired to upset the number 1 ranked, and previously undefeated, Longhorns.
Sleeper - Cam Coleman - Texas - The inarguably third receiver in all pre-season All-America lists behind Smith and Toney has been supplanted by Duff this year but interestingly had his most important performance in the Longhorns' loss to their Red River rivals. Hauled in 5 catches for 110 yards, and again showed his first-round draft pick ability.
Defensive Edition
5. Kingston Lopa - DB - California - Leads the FBS with 5 interceptions. Plus, the fact that he only has 1 Pass Defensed shows that opposing QBs are throwing away from him.
4. Dylan Stewart - EDGE - South Carolina - Finished the game against Florida with 5 total tackles (4 solo) and 1 sack and 1 tackle for loss. However, those stats do not show how disruptive he was the entire game. Should be a high first round draft pick.
3. David Stone - DT - Oklahoma - He had perhaps the single-most impactful game in the NCAA this week. As a DT his numbers will not shine - 5 tackles, 4 solo - but he was so disruptive in the middle of Texas' offensive line that the Longhorns struggled, especially on important downs.
2. Nicholas Rodriguez - LB - Missouri - Stays in the two position for the second straight week He is tied for first in the FBS with 63 total tackles and is a strength for a surprise 5-1 Tigers team.
1. Colin Simmons - Edge - Texas - Leads the FBS with 9 1/2 sacks, after amassing two more against Oklahoma, 7 total tackles, and 3 total tackles for loss. Just a dominant season for Simmons.
Player(s) to Watch
Ty Dieffenbach, QB, UCLA. Dieffenbach definitely did not set the world on fire, but what he did was much, much more important. He entered the game to replace Nico Iamaleava and went 3/6 for 43 yards and 1 TD, and that TD just happened to keep UCLA undefeated in a 17-15 victory over Oregon AT Oregon, despite the Bruins defense giving up 9 points in the last 5:16 of play.
My New Favorite Player
Jordan Maiava - QB, USC - Maiava was 21/33 for 301 yards and 3 TDs in Beaver Stadium as USC defeated Penn State 31-23. Could he actually make the November 28th rivalry game against UCLA important again? USC has a tough schedule before then (Ohio State and Indiana - much more difficult than UCLA's), but if anyone can make that game matter - it is Maiava!!!
Players of the Week (Just Week 4)
6. Jonaz Walton - RB - Notre Dame - The Fighting Irish won in a laugher over Stanford and part of that reason was Walton gaining 181 yards on just 13 carries for a 13.9 yards per carry while also contributing 2 TDs.
5. Braden Atkinson - QB - Oregon State/Jesse Legree - WR - Oregon State - They both led the Beavers to a 66-14 win over San Diego State University with Atkinson throwing for 409 yards and 5 TDs and Legree hauling in 3 of those TDS on 10 catches for 191 yards!!!
4. Charlie Smith - QB - Harvard - He was an incredible 23/27 for 275 yards and 3 TDS - to 3 different receivers - as Harvard erased a 10-0 first quarter deficit at Cornell to win 41-29 and stay undefeated.
3. Bear Bachmeier - QB - BYU - Led the undefeated Cougars to a 24-10 victory over Iowa State in Ames with his arm (22/30 for 329 yards and 2 TDS and his legs (a game-high 109 yards). He is keeping BYU's playoff hopes more than alive with a 5-0 record.
2. Isaac Brown - RB - Louisville - With QB Lincoln Kienholz playing, but hobbled, the Cardinal rushing attack needed to lead the way, and Isaac Brown performed to the tune of 235 yards and 2 TDs on only 17 carries. Louisville defeated Florida State 44-20 after the Seminoles took a first quarter 14-0 lead and seemed poised to pull off the upset.
1. Ty Pennington - QB - Northern Arizona - Pennington had an amazing game as the Lumberjacks defeated Montana 49-44. Pennington threw for 1 TD on 26/38 passing for 322 yards, and also rushed for 52 yards and an incredible 4 TDs!!!
Goat of the Week (Player Edition)
Arch Manning - QB - Texas - K - Besides all of the overblown pre-season Heisman and potential #1 overall draft pick hype, Manning deserved all the love after leading Texas in its fourth quarter come-from-behind victory over Ohio State. Therefore, he has to take the heat for his interception - including during crunch time - against Oklahoma.
Goat of the Week (Coach Edition)
Jon Sumrall/Buster Faulkner - Florida - That Mississippi win was amazing. Well-deserved kudos, and with a high-flying offense definitely looked like they were going to at least make some noise in the SEC, if not sneak into the playoffs. A 45-17 drubbing at the hands of Mississippi and a 38-19 home defeat by South Carolina erases ALL of that, especially since 6 of those 19 came with 1 minute left in the game. Not just that Florida can't seem to break 20 anymore, their offense seems mundane and predictable - that is why Sumrall and Faulkner are here. In fact, it might just be time to play the young sophomore quarterback Tramel Jones, Jr. to get ready for next year, as this team does still seem to be on an upward trajectory. Although a second-consecutive unexpected win against Texas next week could alter things again.
Predicted Playoffs Semi-Final Match Ups
(1) Georgia v. (4) Miami/Notre Dame (2) v. Ohio State (3)
Final Unbeatens
BYU, Georgia, Indiana, James Madison, Miami, Notre Dame, Texas Tech, UCLA, Utah
Rant(s) of the Week
That SEC officiating crew performance in Georgia-Alabama was HORRIFIC. That was one of the more blatant, unintentional pass interferences I have seen in a long time that was not called. Several other calls were questionable in both directions also. For the "Premier" conference in NCAA FBS, the players deserve way better officiating.
Under Performance of the Week
Minnesota Golden Gophers. Throttled by Purdue 41-13 on the road isn't always an underperformance in a big conference, but it is after three victories in a row including a celebrated 20-14 win over Michigan (which I know isn't THAT big a win anymore). Now all 4-2 Minnesota has to look forward to are three games against Iowa, at Indiana and against UCLA. They could be under .500 heading into Happy Valley in mid-November. This week was an important game for bowl/postseason purposes, and Minnesota failed, miserably.
Last Week's Trivia Answer
The question was: Jeremiah Smith's consecutive 200-yard receiving performances inspired this question. What is the most receiving yards in an NCAA game WITHOUT scoring a touchdown?
The answer is: Nate Burleson, Nevada - 326 yards on 12 catches in 2001.
Trivia Question of the Week
Inspired by Kingston Lopa, what is the NCAA FBS record for most interceptions in a season?
Match-up(s) to Watch
6. Harvard v. Holy Cross - As stated last week, so long as Harvard is undefeated, they will remain on this list. After falling down 10-0 in the first quarter, the Crimson blitzed the Big Red to win 41-29. Can Holy Cross keep up?
5. Florida v. Texas - The shine has come off Florida, and Texas took a big beat last week against Oklahoma, but yours truly is going to be in the stands at this game, so it is definitely a must watch for me.
4. Florida State v. Miami - A rivalry game which has lost some luster due to Florida State being horrible, and its coach Mike Norvell likely fired sometime during this season, but these players all grew up playing with and against each other since pee-wee football, so that always brings the emotion in this game.
3. Alabama v. Tennessee - Can Tennessee knock Alabama out of the playoffs? Can Alabama avoid two losses in a row? Big game in the SEC. Similar status as Missouri - Mississippi, except the fact that Alabama is in this game makes this one to watch instead of the other.
2. Ohio State v. Indiana - Obviously a big game as the reigning champions and 5th-ranked Indiana Hoosiers host the 4th-ranked Ohio State Buckeyes. Game Day has selected Bloomington for this week, and an Indiana win could do a lot toward vaulting Indiana into the Big 10 Championship game again, and knocking Ohio State to the brink of missing the playoffs.
1. Notre Dame v. BYU - The playoff implications of this game are HUGE, as BYU could be hurt by a bad loss in this game, causing them to miss the playoffs, even with one loss. Notre Dame's invincibility would be damaged with a BYU win at home. Game Day should be here!
Special Mention of the Week
Florida Atlantic led Texas Southern 21-3 - BEFORE THE OWLS OFFENSE EVEN TOOK THE FIELD1!! Leonard Farrow returned the opening kickoff for a TD. Texas Southern then drove for a FG. Leonard Farrow took the next kickoff for a TD. On Texas Southern's next possession, the defense forced a fumble and returned it for a TD!!!