What a weekend with 7 ranked-on-ranked matchups, with the highlight being Notre Dame's 31-24 victory over Miami; and it wouldn't be Miami at Notre Dame without a refereeing controversy (remember Cleveland Gary?). Awesome football some of the expected close games ... ahem ... weren't.
I have to acknowledge that I missed last week, and I apologize, but between traveling in the early part of the week and my neighborhood being flooded, my attention was focused elsewhere. I will try my best to not miss too many more weeks this season.
Welcome (Back) to the Ole College Try, which is my take on college football via a weekly column on college football after each weekend's games. The column is meant to be a recap of the season to date, with an emphasis on last week's games. I write this column as if every player is a Heisman Trophy candidate. Why? Because it is ridiculously ludicrous (is there any other kind of ludicrous, besides Ludacris?) that the networks, including the World-Wide Leader, nay, especially the World-Wide Leader, emphasize the Heisman Trophy race all season at the expense of everything else. Consider this my sarcastic homage to stupid reporting.
Heisman Watch
Quarterback Edition
Favorite - Darian Mensah - Miami - It isn't often when a 24/43 for 276 yards, 3 TDs and 1 Interception is an awful week for a QB, but that was what occurred here. Notre Dame played really well, and it took Mensah a bit to adjust without Malachi Toney. Once he adjusted in the second-half, he salvaged his position as the top-ranked QB on the Heisman board. His interception against Notre Dame was only his second of the year.
Rising - C.J. Carr - Notre Dame - Not only did he have great numbers against Miami - 29/40 for 319 yards and 3 TDs - he was very composed and led the team. With Malachi Toney's injury keeping him out 4 to 6 weeks, the Heisman finalists are Jeremiah Smith, Mensah, and Carr.
Sleeper - Noah Fifita - Arizona - With all of the hype going to the 6 or 7 possible first-round draft picks in 2027, Fifita is quietly having a fantastic season, as evidenced by this week's game in which he was 24/37 for 313 yards and 2 TDs (with 1 Int) while also gaining 38 yards on the ground in Arizona's 29-28 thrilling victory over TCU.
Falling - Trinidad Chambliss - Mississippi - The talent is amazing, and what he has done for Mississippi the last two years cannot be overstated, but he came back down to earth against Georgia (after a great performance against them in the playoffs last year!) 18-34 for 170 and 0 TDs is not going to get the job done.
Running Back Edition
Favorite - DeSean Bishop - Tennessee - Another 100-yard game against Kentucky - which just so happens to keep Tennessee's chances to make the SEC Championship game alive.
Rising - J'Koby Williams - Texas Tech - Williams gained 160 yards on 19 carries, and earned another 42 yards on 3 catches as Tezas Tech won a shootout over West Virginia 53-48.
Falling - All BYU and Utah RBs - Utah and BYU - Both quarterbacks (Devon Dampier and Bear Bachmeier) led their respective teams in rushing this week in Utah's important 28-20 victory. This has been a recurring theme this year
Sleeper - L.J. Phillips, Jr. - Iowa - Phillips, whose 21 carries in Iowa's 24-10 victory over Northwestern account for almost 40% of his season carries, gained 128 yards (with 14 additional yards through the air), and is becoming an important piece to the Hawkeye's Big 10 Championship dreams (they are currently tied for 3rd!)
Wide Receiver Edition
Favorite - Jeremiah Smith - Ohio State - Even though Ohio State's season is effectively over with its third loss of the year, Smith still produced with 7 catches, 133 yards and 1 TD. Best player in football this season and WILL be a top 3 pick barring injury.
Rising - KJ Duff; Jesse Legree; Charlie Becker; Carlos Hernandez - Rutgers; Oregon State; Indiana; Wake Forest - With Malachi Toney's injury, the second spot in the first-team All-American lists is now up for grabs. These are the best receivers not named Smith or Toney.
Sleeper - Elijah Loftin - Miami - Although a tight end and not a wide receiver, we know who Mensah is going to count on in important moments of games. Loftin caught 7 passes for 113 yards and 1 TD (actually 2 if anybody watched the game) and is too big for safeties to cover and too fast for most linebackers.
Falling - Malachi Toney - Miami - Out 4 to 6 weeks, so likely to return for the playoffs. The Miami offense struggled without him in the first half against Notre Dame, but the second half showed they can still make the playoffs without him - making his return essential for a deep run.
Defensive Edition
5. Ellis Robinson IV - CB - Georgia - The playmaker is fast-rising up draft boards with his shut-down man-to-man coverage skills.
4. Ladainian Fields - CB - Oklahoma State - Leads the FBS with 7 interceptions.
3. Nicholas Rodriguez - LB - Missouri - FBS's leading tackler with 98, would ordinarily be everybody's top defender in the SEC (except this year).
2. Colin Simmons - EDGE - Texas - Tied for the FBS lead with 10 1/2 sacks, even with missing two games. Everyone watching this week's matchup with Missouri saw how much he can control a game from the Edge.
1. Chris Cole - LB - Georgia - Best defender in the NCAA. Can run, tackle, rush, cover - you name it. Led the charge against Trinidad Chambliss as Georgia won handily 42-7.
Player(s) to Watch
Micah Gilbert - WR, Notre Dame. 9 catches for 98 yards and 2 TDs as CJ Carr's primary receiving threat - and he lived up to all of the hype in the much-ballyhooed matchup against then-number 1 Miami.
My New Favorite Player
DJ Gordon - QB/RB, Harvard. Although listed at QB, Gordon lined-up behind Charlie Smith at RB and rushed for 147 yards on only 13 carries for 2 TDs as Harvard trounced Columbia 37-0 and regained the top spot in the Ivy League.
Players of the Week
6. Taylen Taylor - WR - Georgia - Gained 140 yards on only 4 catches, 3 of which went for TDs.
5. Ty Dieffenabach - QB - UCLA - The substitute only went 8-16 in the air, but threw for 303 yards and 3 TDs as UCLA remained undefeated.
4. DJ Gordon - QB/RB - Harvard - 147 yards rushing on 13 carries and 2 TDs in a blowout!
3. Giovanni Richardson - WR - Arizona - 11 catches, 171 yards in a 29-28 victory for the Wildcats over TCU.
2. Thomas Casetllanos - QB - Texas Tech - Had a monster game with 362 yards and 5 TDs on 18/27 passing to keep Tech alive in the Big 12 title race.
1. CJ Carr - QB - Notre Dame - Seriously, did you see him play?!
Goat of the Week (Player Edition)
No player this week - just the officiating staff and the replay officials in the Notre Dame-Miami game as Elijah Loftin scored a TD!
Goat of the Week (Coach Edition)No player this week - just the officiating staff and the replay officials in the Notre Dame-Miami game as Elijah Loftin scored a TD!
Predicted Playoffs Semi-Final Match Ups (By Seeding Only)
(1) Georgia v. (4) Miami (2) Utah v. Notre Dame (3)
Final Unbeatens
FBS - UCLA, Utah
FCS - Tarleton State
Rant(s) of the Week
OK - yes, I am a fan. But that Elijah Loftin catch - WAS A CATCH. He secured the ball (with two hands mind you) and had one foot (actually two feet) in the endzone. To quote Lt. Daniel Kaffey, "These are the facts; and they are indisputable!" Loftin then has to complete the catch by either making a football move, or with enough elapsed time that a football move could have been made. What did Loftin do at that point? He got his second foot in, he brought the ball from the air to his chest, and then he stepped out-of-bounds. All three of those are football moves. One of those by itself completes the catch. Touchdown. Keep in mind this is not a play where Loftin went to the ground, so he does not have to complete the catch through the ground - just through the "football move." And that he did, indisputably, as the contact from the DB occurs after he is out-of-bounds. That, my friends, is a touchdown!
Under Performance of the Week
Mississippi Rebels/Kentucky Wildcats. Take your pick SEC fans. The Wildcats entered their ranked-versus-ranked matchup in Knoxville as the 6th team in the country. Yes, Tennessee is good and they play great at home. But, to lose 34-6 pretty much ruins your season - at least from what it could have been. Similarly, the Rebels welcomed Georgia into the Grove as the 10th ranked team in the country. And again, Georgia was ranked (even favored at number 2) and a great football team, but Mississippi losing 42-7 pushes them out of playoff contention.
Last Week's Trivia Answer
Malachi Toney set a University of Miami single-game record for receptions with 16 against Pittsburgh this week. Whose record did he break? Meaning, who previously held the Miami single-game record for receptions?
13 - Mike Harley in 2021 against Duke and Malachi Toney in 2025 against Pittsburgh
Trivia Question of the Week
Utah and UCLA are the last remaining undefeated teams in FBS. Each has had one number 1 overall NFL draft pick. Who are they, and what year were they were drafted.
Match-up(s) to Watch
6. Harvard v. Pennsylvania - No longer undefeated, but still atop the Ivy League standings and ranked #19 in FCS, Harvard can qualify for the FCS playoffs in it wins out.
5. Wake Forest v. SMU - Wake Forest is the clear second-best team in the ACC, and making it to the ACC Championship game should place the Demon Deacons in the playoffs - if they can avoid another loss until then.
4. Missouri v. Georgia - The Tigers are trying to go into Athens to make a statement; the Bulldogs are trying to solidify themselves as the best team in the NCAA this year.
3. USC v. Indiana - Indiana is the frontrunner to meet Utah in the Big 10 Championship game. USC is one of 6 squads one-game behind Indiana!
2. Texas v. LSU - Since consecutive losses to Oklahoma and Florida, the Longhorns have been playing inspired ball, against quality opponents, in their defeat of Mississippi and Missouri sandwiched around a Mississippi State drubbing! Texas positioning itself to make the playoffs, which will be a virtual guarantee with a win this week in Baton Rouge!
1. Utah v. Arizona - Can Utah remain undefeated in this battle against the dangerous Noah Fifita and the Arizona Wildcats? Could Arizona in Tucson be like UCF in Orlando was to BYU after the Cougars defeated Notre Dame as Utah tries to recover from defeating its rival BYU last week?